By Selwyn Harris
WASHINGTON, D.C. — Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid doesn’t often use anything but measured tones in public political fights.
He is known as a back-room mechanic, using a quiet voice but considerable influence to steer the Democratic party’s agenda.
One issue everyone in Nevada and in Washington, D.C. knows is close to Reid’s heart is Yucca Mountain; the senator’s opposition to it ever becoming a repository for spent nuclear fuel is quite entrenched.
So, it’s likely no surprise then that the public got a rare glimpse of the senator’s inner tiger this week in a story involving Yucca Mountain.
Reid is normally so soft-spoken that reporters who gather for his weekly press gatherings often strain to hear him speak. All the more surprising when he verbally lowered the boom on fellow Democrat Bill Magwood, who until recently was looking to become the NRC’s newest chairman.
During an interview with online news portal Huffington Post this week, Reid let his feelings be known about Magwood.
First, the senator took umbrage at what he said were outright lies that Magwood was imparting about the Yucca Mountain storage facility located north of Pahrump in Nye County.
While Reid made sure to keep his anger in check, he used descriptive words not often heard from such a measured and polished politician.
“You know, when you’re in this government, this business of politics, the only thing that you have is your word,” Reid told a reporter. “I can be as partisan as I have to be, but I always try to be nice. I try never to say bad things about people.
“Bill Magwood is one of the,” — Reid reportedly paused, deciding which adjective to reach for, before picking them all — “most unethical, prevaricating” — he paused again, this time for a reported 10 full seconds — “incompetent people I’ve ever dealt with.”
The senator went on to describe how Magwood lied right to his face.
“The man sat in that chair — right there — and lied to me. I’ve never, ever in my life had anyone do that. Never,” he told the reporter.
In Washington politics, it is said that some members of Congress can get away with lying to constituents; but playing fast and loose with the truth to colleagues is traditionally more than just frowned upon; it’s a good way to make lasting political enemies.
Reid garnered heavy duty support for keeping Yucca closed from President Obama, whom he backed during the 2008 presidential campaign.
Obama won Nevada during his first election, and has maintained the key presidential support necessary to keep Yucca shuttered.
Reid told the Huffington Post that he was assured by senior White House official Pete Rouse that Magwood would fall in line with the administration’s stance and oppose Yucca Mountain.
Turns out, however, that according to Reid Magwood actually worked against efforts to completely close the facility.
Magwood apparently was playing both sides of the debate as part of a political maneuver to win the NRC’s chairmanship.
“That man I will never, ever forget what a treacherous, miserable liar he is. I met with him because Pete Rouse asked me to meet with him. I said, ‘Is he OK on Yucca Mountain?’ Pete said, ‘Yeah.’ So I went through some detail with him as to how important this was to me. ‘Senator, I know this industry like the back of my hand. You don’t have to worry about me,’ [Magwood reportedly told Reid]. And the conversation was much deeper than that.”
The Huffington Post reported that Magwood was instead working with Republicans in an effort to oust NRC Chair Greg Jaczko.
Jaczko resigned in June and Magwood’s name quickly surfaced as a likely replacement. The Obama administration was well aware of Reid’s feelings toward Magwood, and so refused to name Magwood the NRC’s new chair.
The new chair, Allison MacFarlane, will serve until next year.
Reid suggested that Magwood’s political machinations have exposed him as a tool of the nuclear energy industry.
“He’s a first-class rat. He lied to Rouse, he lied to me, and he had a plan. He is a tool of the nuclear industry. A tool,” Reid told the reporter. “Magwood was a shit-stirrer. He did everything he could do to embarrass Greg Jaczko.”
Reid’s support for Jaczko even extended to the former NRC chairman’s legal bills — Reid donated $10,000 to help Jaczko defend himself against Magwood’s allegations.
Allegations that Jaczko was overly forceful with female NRC staffers as well as his push for new safety standards for American nuclear facilities in the wake of the Fukushima disaster helped bring down his chairmanship.
Reid had not been known as a strong supporter of Jaczko. But after discovering Magwood’s role in spreading the allegations changed his opinion.
He was “the first chair that has never been part of the nuclear industry,” Reid said. “That commission was a tool to the nuclear industry. Greg Jaczko, this young guy, he of course worked for me. He was against Yucca Mountain. But they knew that going in.”


The real story here, laid bare by Reid’s own statements in this article, is how a supposedly objective, scientific regulatory agency has political litmus tests for prospective commissioners, and how potential appointees are asked to commit to a specific agenda (of a politician) and to rule a certain way, regardless of what the science says and/or before the results of objective scientific evaluations are in.
Reid’s intention was to only allow commissioners who would promise to vote (and act) against the Yucca Mountain project, regardless of what science says. Now he’s whining because one commissioner said or implied that he would do so (had to, to get the job) and now he’s “going back on his word” and actually acting objectively.
Keep in mind that Reid blackmailed Bush into appointing Jaczko by blocking all federal judge appointments (an extraordinary act, and an abuse of the Senate Majority Leader position) until he got his way. Jaczko had no background in nuclear engineering. His only “qualification” was his position as a former Reid staffer and his promise to do everything in his power to block Yucca, if appointed.
The same story basically applies with Jaczko’s replacement: a geologist who knows little about reactors but has opposed Yucca Mountain (apparently the only qualification needed to be the head of the NRC, as far as Reid is concerned). One has to wonder if a similar backroom deal was made between Reid and the newly-confirmed chairman, Allison Macfarlane.
If Reid’s actions aren’t illegal, they should be. This is a classic example of undue influence — not to mention politics trumping science.
All politicians lie, to achieve their goals. Lie or tell the truth about Yucca Mtn. does not really matter in the big picture. We do not need a deadly poison sitting in our back yard. Some say it’s safe I say B. S. there is not any tech. out here now that can insure a safe container for 10,000 years. So if you want it there you are a fool!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reid and the other 534 members of congress have only one goal, to get reelected.
They don’t care about us at all.
Vote them all out.
Selwyn, I honestly have to say that you wrote an editorial instead of a news story.
Reid will never hit a man when he’s down, he’ll just kick ‘em as it’s easier.