By Matt Ward
Timothy Lee Hobbs is going to be a free man.
A panel of the Nevada Supreme Court reversed the 44-year-old’s stiff prison sentence on Thursday.
Hobbs, a six-time felon, has been locked away at High Desert State Prison for the past two years.
The late Judge John Davis sentenced Hobbs to a maximum of 25 years in prison for essentially spitting on his girlfriend during a 2008 domestic dispute in front of a Pahrump hair salon. The spitting, though a misdemeanor, was made a felony charge because Hobbs reportedly had two prior domestic battery convictions. Davis also sentenced him as a habitual offender because of the prior batteries.
On Thursday, the northern panel of the Nevada Supreme Court partially reversed Davis’ decision. The justices said prosecutors failed to offer the right kind of proof that Hobbs indeed had two prior domestic batteries at the time of his sentencing in Davis’ court.
State law requires that a domestic battery conviction within seven years of another domestic battery conviction must be proved at the time of sentencing before a judge can consider the defendant a habitual criminal.
The justices who decided the case heard arguments from two local attorneys — Hobbs’ defense attorney Harry Kuehn and prosecutor Wes White, a Nye County deputy district attorney — in December during a special hearing at Pahrump Valley High School.
Two issues were before the judges in December. One was whether spitting on his girlfriend constituted battery and the other was whether prosecutors actually proved the prior convictions.
The panel, consisting of justices Michael Cherry, Nancy Saitta and Mark Gibbons, agreed with prosecutors that the spitting did constitute battery under state law.
According to an opinion written by Justice Saitta and released by the court on Thursday, “the language and meaning of NRS 200.481 is clear; at a minimum, battery is the intentional and unwanted exertion of force upon another, however slight. Because the record clearly demonstrates that Hobbs intentionally spat on (his former girlfriend) and because spitting on another amounts to the use of force or violence as contemplated by NRS 200.481, we conclude that Hobbs was properly convicted.”
However, on the second issue, the justices make clear in their opinion that “the State failed to prove the existence and constitutional validity of Hobbs’ prior domestic battery misdemeanor convictions and therefore that the enhancement of the domestic battery to a felony and the subsequent adjudication of Hobbs as a habitual criminal were erroneous.”
The justices remanded Hobbs’ case back to District Court, where Kuehn said a judge will have no choice but to release Hobbs.
“He should have only gotten six months and he’s served two years,” the public defender said.
It was unclear how quickly Hobbs would be freed.
White was not available for comment as of press time.


I wish that my dads (Michael Frasher) case had a judge like the late Judge Davis.
A 6 time felon?
We need a new Nevada supreme court.
Just because someone has prior felony convictions doesn’t mean they should be sentenced unfairly. Come on people! Really?!?!? 25 years for spitting? That is abuse of power at it’s finest. Murderers get less time. Does anyone know this man? Does anyone know if he had straightened out his life and was trying to do the right thing? Does anyone know if he would commit another domestic battery and get the judgement that was truly coming to him? This counrty is all about second chances. Some of us don’t learn after the second chance. It took me 4 times to learn. Yes, I’m a convicted felon who is a contributing member of society. I raise my kids and pay my taxes like everyone else. If, however, some judge had decided that I wasn’t worth it and had locked me up and thrown away the key I would have never had the chance to become the descent person that I am today. My point is, the punishment should fit the crime and just because a person has a record misdemeanors shouldn’t be treated as felonies.
Got to keep that infamous Revolving Door of court “customers” turning, and churning. Guys like Hobbs are keeping the System in the green.
Yet another case from Nye County, prosecuted by a Deputy DA, that is getting over turned. Hey Kunzi! Wake up and realize that the Deputy DA’s working under you, that were there under Beckett are incompetent……They are falsely prosecuting cases that the Sheriff’s Office writes bad reports…..You have investigators, use them properly and dont prosecute bad cases.
Kunzi is fully aware of the idiots like Vitto and White that work under him in the criminal division and he still allows them to operate. While I think that he is 100% better than Kent would have been, Kunzi plays ball with the corrupt officials and because of this will be anything more than a one term D.A.
Judge Davis was right 6 felonies.
John Davis thought from his heart.
To bad the Judge is gone.
A GREAT person.