48°F
weather icon Clear

Temporary stay issued in Pahrump water order case

The Nevada Supreme Court has issued a temporary stay in the case of Water Order #1293A, allowing the Nevada state engineer, for the moment, to continue requiring water rights relinquishments for all new domestic wells drilled in Pahrump.

The temporary stay comes as part of the appeal process, with the state engineer going to the Nevada Supreme Court after a district court judge ruled against the office in the lawsuit brought forward by Pahrump Fair Water.

However, it is only a temporary stay and it is possible that the Nevada Supreme Court could reverse that stay after considering the opposition provided by Pahrump Fair Water.

“This is an appeal from a district court order granting a petition for judicial review in a water law case and reversing State Engineer Order #1293A restricting the drilling of new domestic wells,” the Nevada Supreme Court document states.

“Appellant state engineer has filed an emergency motion to stay the district court’s order pending appeal. Having considered appellant’s motion and supporting documents, we conclude that a temporary stay is warranted pending our receipt and consideration of any opposition from respondents… Accordingly, we stay enforcement of the district court’s December 6, 2018, order granting judicial review and reversing State Engineer Order #1293A, pending further order of this court.”

The court also ordered an expedited response from Pahrump Fair Water, which was filed on Jan. 9.

In its opposition to motion for emergency stay, the group argues first that the state engineer’s likelihood of succeeding in its appeal is small because it is undeniable that the engineer issued Order #1293 and #1293A without providing advance notice to any of the affected parties. This, Pahrump Fair Water declares, and the lower district court agreed, was a violation of due process.

The opposition goes on to reiterate the stance that the engineer’s office does not have authority over domestic wells, except in very specific instances, “…that do not arise here,” the filing reads. Lastly, the group argues that the engineer’s object of appeal will not be frustrated by a lack of stay and conversely, Pahrump Fair Water’s members would suffer irreparable harm if a more permanent stay is issued.

As to be expected, the opposite positions are presented in the state engineer’s motion for emergency stay.

The engineer claimed the potential for irreparable harm to the office, noting that if the Nevada Supreme Court ultimately decides to grant the appeal, overturn the lower court decision and reinstate Order #1293A, hundreds or even thousands of domestic wells could have been drilled in violation of the water order. This would create “procedural disarray,” the engineer’s office asserted.

The document also cited fears of declining water levels if domestic wells continue to be drilled without water rights relinquishments.

“Despite the district court’s finding to the contrary, the state engineer will argue that he did in fact have authority to issue amended Order #1293A to prohibit the drilling of new domestic wells without the relinquishment of a 2-acre-foot water right, that it was supported by substantial evidence, and that he did not violate due process in issuing the amended order. As the district court stated during the hearing on Nov. 8, 2018, this case presents a tight issue. Therefore, the likelihood of success on the merits should not weigh in either side’s favor, and should certainly not work in petitioners’ favor to defeat this motion for stay,” the engineer’s filing states.

To view all documents related to this appeal visit www.nvcourts.gov and search for case number 77722.

Contact reporter Robin Hebrock at rhebrock@pvtimes.com

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
THE LATEST
Nevada Highway Patrol receives $100k public safety grant

By putting in additional efforts to combat drunk and distracted drivers along Silver State roadways, the Nevada Department of Public Safety, Highway Patrol Division has received a grant in the amount of $100,000 from the Nevada Department of Public Safety, Office of Traffic Safety for targeted DUI enforcement campaigns during the coming year.

Fire restrictions lifted at Humboldt-Toiyabe

The ban and other restrictions, which previously applied only to federal lands such as the Humbldt-Toiyabe National Forest, have been expanded to all public lands in Nevada.

FDA pushes for reduction in salt in packaged foods, restaurants

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration released guidance on Wednesday in an effort to reduce the amount of salt in food products at restaurants, school cafeterias and packaged and prepared foods. Food makers, however, are not obligated to take action in the voluntary guidance.

Social Security benefits to rise 5.9% in 2022

The Social Security Administration announced a cost-of-living raise of 5.9% starting in 2022, the largest annual increase in 40 years. The rise, however, comes in the face of other increases in food, shelter and other goods.

Solar project discussion riles Pahrump citizens

The Pahrump Public Lands Advisory Committee had what may very well have been the biggest turnout the advisory body has ever seen before during its Tuesday, Oct. 12 meeting.

Pumpkin Days returns to Pahrump next weekend

Fall is in the air and for the town of Pahrump, that means it’s almost time for Pumpkin Days.

Adam Laxalt stumps in Pahrump

U.S. Senate candidate Adam Laxalt made a stop in the valley last week, spending some time at local eatery Mom’s Diner to speak with area residents as he ramps up his campaign for the 2022 election.

Pahrump local’s Kids Costume Car Wash a success

Pahrump resident Shauna “Shay” Dragna and her three youngsters, Cayleigh, Caden and Conner, have spent the last month focusing on their very first public philanthropy project and though they entered into the endeavor without any previous experience and absolutely no idea how it might turn out, the results of their efforts are bearing some very positive fruit.

 
Cegavske won’t allow tax petitions off 2022 ballot

Nevada Secretary of State Barbara Cegavske has told Attorney General Aaron Ford in a letter the state constitution doesn’t allow for petitions to be withdrawn.