95°F
weather icon Clear

EDITORIAL: Court puts washing machine regulation in spin cycle

The “Schoolhouse Rock” song “I’m Just a Bill” is a classic. But it doesn’t explain the modern regulatory state.

Last year, the Biden administration proposed major restrictions on dishwashers and washing machines. It sought to limit the amount of water and energy new versions of those appliances could use. This was supposed to appease leftist climate warriors but would, in fact, be virtually useless in addressing global temperatures.

“Schoolhouse Rock” aficionados might assume they know what happened next: Mr. Biden had a Democratic member of Congress introduce a bill to regulate the appliances. After all, according to the ditty, that’s how a bill becomes a law.

But Mr. Biden didn’t go to Congress. Such a move would have been politically perilous. Instead, the Department of Energy unilaterally proposed new regulations. It told companies, for instance, that new dishwashers could use only 3.2 gallons of water per cycle, instead of the current 5 gallons. Leave aside the impossibility of identifying where the Constitution gives federal bureaucracy the authority to tell private companies how much water a dishwasher can use.

The problem should be obvious. The Biden administration sought to make a change that would affect hundreds of millions of Americans. But there was no open debate about it in Congress. The elected representatives of the people — senators and House members — didn’t vote on the proposal or even discuss it. Instead, federal bureaucrats wrote a regulation that, once implemented, would have the force of law.

Defenders of an active administrative state argue that Congress delegates rule-making authority to agency “experts.” But this runs contrary to the constitutional system designed by the Founding Fathers, making a mockery of the separation of powers, particularly for new rules that will cost billions and touch almost every American.

In this instance, 11 states filed a lawsuit challenging the regulation. There is good news on that front. This month, the Fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals struck it down.

“It is unclear that DOE has any statutory authority to regulate water use in dishwashers and clothes washers,” the ruling said. Further, it failed to adequately consider if “DOE’s conservation standards are causing Americans to use more energy and water rather than less.”

This is a positive step. And there’s hope on the deeper issue here, too. As we noted Friday, the U.S. Supreme Court heard a case this week that could overturn a 40-year-old legal decision that has given federal bureaucrats cover to both make and enforce laws.

If the president wants to impose restrictions on dishwashers and washing machines, he should head to Capitol Hill and urge Congress to debate and pass a bill.

This commentary initially appeared in the Las Vegas Review-Journal.

THE LATEST
Election Day 2024: What to know

Tuesday marks voters’ last chance to cast their ballot in Nevada’s primary election.

EDITORIAL: A retail theft conspiracy?

Many on the left accuse greedy capitalists at major outlets of exaggerating the problem to cover up mismanagement.

Dutch visitor dies while driving in Death Valley

The approximately 70-year-old man and his wife were visiting from Holland. The man went unconscious while driving on Artist’s Drive. His wife stopped the vehicle safely and moved her husband to the back seat.

Tram tower vandal comes forward

The individual responsible for pulling over the 113-year-old salt tram in Death Valley National Park called the tip line, stating that this was done during a time of desperation while being deeply stuck in mud, and that it wasn’t their intent to cause harm to the historic structure.

Historic Saline Valley salt tram tower pulled down

DEATH VALLEY, Calif. – The National Park Service is seeking information about recent damage to a historic salt tram tower in Saline Valley. It appears the 113-year-old tower was pulled over while a person used a winch to extract their vehicle out of deep mud. The damage happened sometime between April 1 and April 24.

 
Need a Real ID? Time is running out to get one in Nevada

To meet federal requirements, Real IDs will be needed for anyone looking to use their driver’s license to get through security at airports for domestic flights nationwide.

Circus coming to Pahrump

The Kiwanis Club of Pahrump Valley is sponsoring the Hugo, Oklahoma-based Culpepper and Merriweather Great Combined Circus which is coming to Pahrump at Petrack Park on Saturday, May 4 and Sunday, May 5. There will be two 90-minute shows each day at 2 p.m. and 4:30 p.m., with a free tent-raising and behind-the-scenes tour starting at 9:30 a.m. on Saturday.

Devils Hole pupfish population at 25-year high

The spring count of the Devils Hole pupfish, one of the world’s rarest fishes, showed that the population is at its highest since the spring count taken in 1999.

Sportsman’s Quest: You always remember the firsts

While looking through my old picture albums I noticed many of the pictures, and the ones I enjoy most, are of firsts – pictures of my first deer, first bear, first sheep, and first salmon. Perhaps this shouldn’t be surprising, as our memories of first events are often most vivid, and we have a special feeling for other firsts as well.

Meet the new manager for the Nye County Animal Shelter

A little more than a year and a half ago, the new 79-dog capacity no-kill Nye County Animal Shelter opened and promptly received a baptism by fire a few days later when more than 300 abused and neglected Caucasian shepherds were seized, overwhelming the facility’s capacities and resources, and capturing national headlines. These days, the shelter has returned to its normal intended function but with new leadership in place.