weather icon Clear

Dennis Myers: Nevada Gov. Steve Sisolak cast a veto against the founders

In his veto of Assembly Bill 186, Gov. Steve Sisolak argues that he is speaking for the founding fathers (they were all men) in their cutting and splicing of the Virginia Plan and the New Jersey Plan at the constitutional convention when they were trying to placate not the small states but the slave states, most of which happened to be the small ones.

First of all, the Virginia and New Jersey plans dealt with legislative apportionment and A.B. 186 deals with presidential electors, and one can be dealt with without affecting the other, but set that aside. What is more to the point is that Sisolak could only be speaking for the founders’ version of the presidential electors system if we used it. We don’t.

The system they devised (which is not an electoral college, by the way—the Constitution forbids electors from meeting collegially) was one system. We use a different one.

1. The founders wanted political parties kept out of the functioning of the presidential electors system. But in the years after the constitutional convention, legislators who were members of political parties usurped the founders’ system and turned the system over to the parties. Today, presidential electors are nominated in state party conventions and are what U.S. Supreme Court Justices Robert Jackson and William O. Douglas called “party lackeys and intellectual non-entities” instead of the independent leaders that the founders wanted.

2. That leads to another change the parties made in the system. The founders wanted the electors to be free agents, able to vote in the public interest. But partisan state legislators passed state laws that bind electors to vote for the political parties that nominated them. In the founders’ vision, if the public elected a Hitler, the electors would be free to overturn such a result. They are not.

3. The founders did not want states to have winner-take-all systems. They expected electors to represent districts – a proportional system. James Madison, known as the “father of the Constitution,” knew that winner-take-all victimized the slave (small) states and said the founders had district elections “mostly, if not exclusively” in mind for presidential electors. But the political parties have saddled the country with winner-take-all systems in every state except Nebraska and Maine.

These changes from the founders’ vision may serve the needs of the political parties, though it’s hard to see how it serves Sisolak’s Democratic Party, given that every single elected president who was deposed by the electors and replaced with an appointed president was a Democrat.

But it is hardly the presidential electors system the founders created, nor is Sisolak advocating or defending the founders’ creation.

Dennis Myers is an award-winning journalist who has reported on Nevada’s capital, government and politics for several decades. He has also served as Nevada’s chief deputy secretary of state.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
Tim Burke: Illegal dumping shows lazy, inconsiderate attitude

The used and broken sofa appeared alongside the roadway overnight. Laying on its side, it was just a few feet from the shoulder of the paved two-lane rural road. At first glance, you may have thought that it might have fallen off a truck by accident, but a longer look showed that it wasn’t alone, there were a couple of plants and other trash next to it.

TIM BURKE: Time to return government control to local jurisdiction

Once upon a time, normal everyday citizens had access to their senators and congresspersons. You could call one of these elected officials and actually get to talk to them. Even better, you could stop by their office and see them face to face and have an opportunity to discuss issues directly with them.

Thomas Knapp: Impeachment: The Problem with Biden Whataboutism

The main Democratic impeachment charge against president Donald Trump is simple: Trump attempted to pressure and/or bribe the president of Ukraine to investigate a political opponent (Joe Biden), House impeachment managers say, both for corrupt motives (to win re-election) and in violation of the law (by withholding congressionally appropriated aid).

Thomas Knapp: Afghanistan, Oh, when will we ever learn?

“U.S. officials failed to tell the truth about the war in Afghanistan throughout the 18-year campaign,” the Washington Post’s Craig Whitlock reports. “Making rosy pronouncements they knew to be false and hiding unmistakable evidence the war had become unwinnable.”

Tim Burke: Stargazing makes most things seem insignificant

Stargazing is popular here in the Mojave Desert away from the bright lights of Las Vegas. Death Valley National Park holds its Dark Sky Festival this February 21-23, 2020. This event is a collaboration between the park, Death Valley Natural History Association, NASA, and many other organizations. Death Valley offers some of the best stargazing in America. The International Dark-Sky Association has designated Death Valley National Park as a Gold Tier Dark Sky Park, the highest rating of darkness.