75°F
weather icon Clear

Possible new VEA policy: Censorship

Valley Electric Association officials recently chafed at suggestions that the cooperative is less than forthcoming about its operations.

This newspaper in particular has been on the receiving end of management’s ire over the subject — mostly because covering the co-op in any meaningful way requires asking hard questions and getting straight answers that managers seem strangely reluctant to give.

One example: A multi-million dollar facility is slated to be built at the co-op’s Pahrump campus in a matter of months, yet the price tag for the new facility as well as renovations to existing buildings continues to elude the public, though to be sure VEA ratepayers will be footing the bill and have a real interest in how much this project is costing them.

And now the cooperative’s board is being asked to mull a policy change that may in fact reduce the ability of news media from covering the cooperative even further.

The item came up for discussion during VEA’s regular board of directors meeting on Friday. VEA CEO Tom Husted, in describing the suggested policy, appeared to be telling board members that they could use it to censor the press, and even stymie co-op members who wish to attend meetings and then discuss what was said to the media.

“If the board of directors determines any member who attends or wishes to attend a regular or special meeting should be primarily interested in using association information obtained at such a meeting in a manner the board determines to be adverse to the best interests of the association, which may include the intent to publish the association’s information in any public forum or media outlet, the board of directors may deny that member access to the meeting or the alternative, the board may require the member to agree not to use the information received in a manner adverse to the association prior to that member’s entry to the meeting,” he said.

Husted framed his remarks on not just the need to protect sensitive co-op information, but also the need to be able to move meetings smoothly along. He addressed, for example, public comment at the meetings as well.

“If we were going through our board meeting financials and you had 30 people with questions, it would really lengthen the board meeting and make it very disjointed. We usually have a small enough crowd and this board has been a little relaxed on that and has allowed questions from members as we go through the meeting. Obviously, those rules would have to be tightened if you had a hundred people in here for every board meeting,” he said.

VEA typically provides lengthy summaries of its financial picture at every board of directors meeting, and did so again Friday. Media requests for copies of those reports, however, are routinely denied this newspaper for less than clear reasons, particularly since the figures are stated openly during a public forum that can ostensibly be attended by anyone.

Still, Husted seemed to want to portray to board members that his suggestions for the new policy were not meant to make VEA’s operations less transparent, though he continued to single out the role of the press.

“The genesis for this is that we want to be as open and transparent as we possibly can. We have members here today who have taken the time to be an active participant in the company they own and we respect that. We also believe that our members should be allowed to participate in and hear the actions of their cooperative, but at the same time we have a legal responsibility to this company and we may have actions that are taking place and we would love for our members to know what those business plans are and what those actions are. But when we have a member who is here not only as a member but is a member who owns maybe a communications company and they are doing the part of their job and they are communicating not only to our members but to the entire world,” he said, “the entire world is not always in unison and friendly to Valley Electric and is a competitor.”

Not every board member seemed to be on board with what Husted was suggesting.

Dave Lowe, district 5 director, was one of them. He said the board, like it or not, is a quasi-government body and that facts should flow freely for better decision making, if nothing else. He compared the policy changes being discussed with something more akin to Eastern Bloc, Cold War style communist doctrine.

“The danger that we get into is that you want to proofread the reporter’s piece and that would be one way to do it and that is just the thing we have tried to avoid with the idea of a free press. All of the members need protection and that includes everyone in this room, not just certain members. I think that this prudence of ensuring that only the party line gets out is very dangerous. We have seen that happen before in this country 200 years ago. But also in other countries even today, especially in the Iron Curtain. They had very accurate reporting according to the leadership,”he said.

Lowe added that he thought being too extreme with local media members would also not be a good image for the cooperative to cultivate with the public.

“I don’t want to do anything that makes us appear that we are the villains. In this case, my attitude is that the members of the press who are also members of Valley Electric are not coming in here to sabotage Valley Electric, it’s their own company, why would they?”

Husted agreed that the cooperative was in a tough spot.

“That is a tough quandary. We have to be very mindful of that, but we also want to be very respectful to our members, which may own or work for a company that is communicating on a larger scale beyond our membership. We have a fiduciary responsibility to protect this company. We also have a responsibility to serve the best interests of the members. We do not have a fiduciary responsibility to act on the best behalf of the member’s (media) company,” he told the board.

The CEO also pointed out multiple times that the policy discussion was just that, a discussion, and that no action would be taken until something more concrete was brought back to the board for a vote.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
THE LATEST
IN SEASON: Okra, a southern favorite for your western garden

Okra may be considered a staple crop in the American South, but it also grows very well in our hot dry climate. As a member of the mallow family, it puts on a stunning display of delicate yellow flowers.

Special legislative session scheduled to open Friday

Gov. Steve Sisolak on Thursday issued the formal proclamation to call the Nevada Legislature into a special session beginning 9 a.m. Friday, July 31 to address significant policy issues that cannot wait until the regularly scheduled legislative session. This will be the 32nd special session in Nevada’s history.

Report chronicles massive decline in fish populations

With hydroelectric power, overfishing, climate change and pollution on the rise, monitored populations of migratory freshwater fish species have plummeted by 76% on average since 1970, according to the first comprehensive global report on the status of freshwater migratory fish issued this week by the World Fish Migration Foundation and Zoological Society of London.

AngloGold Ashanti gains exploration project permit

The administrator of the Division of Environmental Protection has decided to issue a reclamation permit for an exploration project to AngloGold Ashanti North America.

Immunizations remain required part of back-to-school routines

As parents continue to navigate what back to school looks like this year, one aspect of the ritual that hasn’t changed is making sure kids are up to date on their vaccines. Whether families choose in-person, hybrid or distance learning models for the fall 2020 school session, Nevada law requires immunizations for child care, school and university entry, with the exception of religious exemptions or a medical condition.

DMV will offer renewals online, by mail this fall

Nevada motorists who have been unable to make an appointment at DMV offices before their expiration date will benefit from two new initiatives announced Tuesday by the Department of Motor Vehicles.

Nye County Civic Center proposal presented

In 2016, when Valley Electric Association was aiming to sell a 200-kilovolt transmission line and needed a vote of approval by its members in order to do so, one of the selling points for that sale was the promise that if it went through, VEA would donate $5 million toward the construction of a new community center. It may have taken nearly three years after the transmission sale was executed but VEA did finally make good on that promise, offering the $5 million donation to Nye County, with the Nye County Commission voting to accept it in September 2019.

NCSD superintendent lays out school reopening plans

Earlier this month, the Nye County School District Board of Trustees approved the district’s COVID-19 re-entry plan, which laid out three models for returning students and staff to school safely.

Pahrump elementary schools to observe hybrid education model

With less than a month left before youth across Nye County are scheduled to begin the new school year, the Nye County School District has announced a change in its school re-entry plans, switching Pahrump area K-5 schools from the originally selected 100% in-person education model to the hybrid model that requires students to conduct their learning online three days out of the five-day school week.