63°F
weather icon Partly Cloudy
Pahrump, NV
Opinion

Letter: Yucca Mountain advocacy tarnished

Pahrump Valley Times
June 15, 2016 - 6:01 am
 

Recent “Community Viewpoints” these past two Friday’s in the Times reflect a myopic absolutism and mis-information about atomic power that has been characteristic of arguments against the Yucca Mountain repository for spent nuclear fuels (SNF’s).

Downplaying the ecological damage by Chernobyl and Fukushima detracts from the credibility of the Messrs. Gran and McCracken to plot a realistic future for nuclear fission and assess the risks of Yucca Mountain.

How electricity is to be generated and where to store SNF’s are two separate issues.

There are now many more fuel rods that need to be disposed of thanks to President Carter’s 1977 decision not to reprocess the waste. Yet it is Carter’s fellow Democrats led by Senator Reid who are most in denial about taking the last essential step for safely decommissioning over one hundred power plants around the country.

None of these plants were located with a view towards long-term geologic stability and a low water table for storing the rods onsite.

Rather it was proximity to a body of water for cooling their reactors, as well to barge in components for their construction.

So it is reckless for the Department of Energy to now propose either indefinite onsite storage, or shipping the SNF’s hither and yonder when nearly half the objections to the recent EIS filed by DOE concerned cross-country transportation of the SNF’s, not their final location.

Consider the Rancho Seco plant near Sacramento contracting with a firm in Texas to transport the SNF’s across Nevada and Utah for internment in a facility that cannot be as far above groundwater as Yucca Mountain.

Replicate this folly for over 100 reactors scattered around the country for an unimaginable security burden compared to what is needed to monitor shipments all headed to one single point.

Failure to complete the centralized repository is as much a calamity for the entire nation as it is a setback for Nye County.

Estimates for each utility to make their own arrangements range up to $250 billion for America’s ratepayers – several times more than what it would cost to have coordinated shipment via rail expanded to take all of the radioactive materials now going via truck through Pahrump into the Nevada Test Site.

Sincerely,

Bill Stremmel

MOST READ
LISTEN TO THE TOP FIVE HERE
THE LATEST
Getty Images
Letters to the Editor

Where did all these experts on international law and UCMJ law (Uniform Code of Military Justice) come from?

Getty Images
Letters to the Editor

Today we see the legal and moral resistance against deporting illegal aliens, and it has become a real problem for the United States.

Getty Images
Letters to the Editor

It’s time to address the inequalities in our nation, not point fingers over who is patriot or not. We’re all Americans first and foremost.

Getty Images
Letters to the Editor

After reading the letter from a “moderate Republican”, with a severe case of TDS,

Eric Coleman/Pahrump Valley Times
BOVEE — Election results: What does it all mean?
By Philip S. Bovee Special to the Pahrump Valley Times

First, something it doesn’t mean: the Nov. 4 election is not a wholesale rejection of Trump and his policy.

(Getty Images)
Letters to the Editor

Government shutdowns are becoming almost like ‘political holidays’ for so many in government.

Getty Images
Letters to the Editor

As a moderate Republican I am just shaking my head at the mindless automatons we actually call elected officials who have been storming around causing complete chaos on Capitol Hill for two weeks.