weather icon Mostly Cloudy

DIVAS ON A DIME: Bake up some joy on National Peanut Butter Cookie Day

There’s a “day” for nearly everything, but here is a holiday so good, its nuts! Or perhaps rather, legumes? This Saturday, June 12, is National Peanut Butter Cookie Day.

Over the years I’ve baked my share of peanut butter cookies, usually the good old-fashioned drop cookie made by creaming butter with sugar and adding flour and baking powder, etc. But not anymore. Since trying this simpler, easier approach, I’m never going back. I know you’ll love it too.

The recipe I’m sharing needs only five ingredients for sweet, salty, crunchy, chewy, delectable cookies. Like most cookies, they’re best warm from the oven with a glass of milk.

One thing to love about this recipe is the simplicity. It’s a perfect cookie to make with kids who are learning to bake. It’s very tactile with lots of stirring and rolling stuff in sugar which is especially great for the very young (or young at heart). And since it doesn’t contain flour, it’s ideal for people with gluten allergies. To top it off, it’s very inexpensive.

Don’t waste your money buying natural peanut butter, where the oil separates from the solids, it doesn’t work with this recipe. Buy the cheap stuff! Those with peanut allergies can substitute almond butter or sunflower butter.


What You’ll Need:

1 (16-ounce) peanut butter (2 cups)

1 cup packed light brown sugar

2 large eggs, beaten

2 teaspoons vanilla extract

½ teaspoon kosher salt

Optional – ¼ cup granulated or demerara sugar – for rolling

Here’s How:

Please remember, any time kids use the oven, adult supervision is required. Preheat your oven to 350°F, placing the racks in upper and lower thirds. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper.

In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, or a large bowl using elbow grease and a rubber spatula, mix or stir the peanut butter and brown sugar until combined.

Add eggs, vanilla, and salt then mix or stir once again to thoroughly combine.

Shape dough into walnut-sized balls and if desired, roll in sugar to coat. That makes a delightfully sparkly exterior that’s so pretty. Place them 2 inches apart on prepared baking sheets. Using the tines of a fork, press down to flatten each ball and then press again at a 90°-degree angle, to form the iconic criss-cross pattern on top.

Bake cookies until edges are set and beginning to brown, about 12 minutes, rotating baking sheets top to bottom and back to front halfway through cooking time. Makes about 38 cookies.

Why do we press peanut butter cookies with a fork? Because peanut butter cookie dough is usually very dense. Flattening them slightly allows for more even baking. The fork marks also make it easier for those with peanut allergies to spot them.

You’re going to love this recipe so much and I don’t want you to get tired of it! So, I’ve included some easy variations to this basic recipe to shake up your peanut butter palate.

Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies – Prepare recipe as directed. For filling – With a hand mixer, blend ½ cup creamy peanut butter, 3 cups confectioners’ sugar, 1 teaspoon vanilla extract and 5 to 6 tablespoons milk until light and fluffy. Place a spoonful between two baked cookies to make a sandwich.

Extra Crunchy – Prepare recipe as directed, stirring in 1 cup chopped dry-roasted, salted peanuts before shaping and baking.

Oatmeal Raisin – Prepare recipe as directed, stirring in 1 cup old-fashioned regular rolled oats, ½ cup raisins, and 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon before shaping and baking.

Chocolate Pretzel – Prepare recipe as directed, stirring in ½ to 1 cup semisweet or milk chocolate chips, and 1 cup chopped pretzels before shaping. You won’t be able to make a crosshatch pattern so just flatten slightly with the palm of your hand.

I can’t write about peanut butter without acknowledging George Washington Carver, the American agricultural extension educator from Alabama, and passionate peanut proponent.

In 1925 Professor Carver wrote a research bulletin called “How to Grow the Peanut and 105 Ways of Preparing it for Human Consumption”.

It included three recipes for peanut cookies calling for crushed or chopped peanuts. Although those recipes didn’t specifically call for peanut butter (that didn’t happen until the 1930’s) I say, close enough! Thank you, Professor Carver! Today we raise a glass of milk and dip a peanut butter cookie in your honor.

Lifestyle expert Patti Diamond is the recipe developer and food writer of the website “Divas On A Dime – Where Frugal, Meets Fabulous!” Food photography by www.JasonCoblentz.com . Visit Patti at www.divasonadime.com and join the conversation on Facebook at DivasOnADimeDotCom. Email Patti at divapatti@divasonadime.com

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
California Lottery

No one matched all five numbers and the mega number in the Wednesday, August 4 drawing of the California Super Lotto. The next jackpot will be at least $14 million.

DIVAS ON A DIME: Spoil dad with gourmet hamburgers at home

With Father’s Day just around the corner, may I suggest giving dear old dad what he really wants, an amazing hamburger. Seriously, who doesn’t love a big, tender, juicy burger? Except for a few vegetarians, every dad I know would agree.

California lottery

No one matched all five numbers and the mega number in the Saturday, June 12 drawing of the California Super Lotto. The next jackpot will be at least $55 million.

DIVAS ON A DIME: Start grilling season with a twist on burnt ends

Memorial Day weekend fills my heart with gratitude as we honor those who made possible, the freedom we so often take for granted. It’s a weekend of recognition, remembrance, and thanks. For many families, this weekend also signals the official beginning of grilling season. Care to join me in a patriotic foodie-licious happy dance?

DIVAS ON A DIME: Celebrate strawberries and cream with a vintage cake recipe

Each year on May 21st we celebrate a dessert that just squeals Spring! National Strawberries and Cream Day brings together two favorites, fresh ripe strawberries, and homemade whipped cream. While that alone makes a divine dessert, let’s add a mildly sweet, vanilla fragranced, easy to make from scratch cake and we’ve just won at life.

DIVAS ON A DIME: Meet the underrated and versatile baked potato

Remember baked potatoes? I was chatting with friends about food (because what else do I talk about?) and none of us could remember the last time we had stuffed baked potatoes for dinner. We’ve been so busy with our quinoa we forgot about the King of Carbs. Good carbs, naturally.

Make Mother a sandwich that she will never forget

Meet smörgåstårta, your new favorite party recipe. Smörgåstårta (pronounced SMORE-gas-TOR-ta) is simply a beautifully decorated savory sandwich cake. It’s popular when celebrating special occasions in Sweden. To celebrate Mother’s Day and honor the influential women in your life, may I suggest serving a smörgåstårta?

DIVAS ON A DIME: Easy pork carnitas are perfect for Cinco de Mayo

Melt-in-your-mouth, flavorful and juicy with irresistible caramelized crunchy bits, this pork carnitas is brimming with classic flavors like Mexican oregano, cumin, chili powder and a surprising bright note of citrus. I’m so excited to share this divine recipe, just in time for Cinco de Mayo.

California Lottery

No one matched all five numbers and the mega number in the Saturday, March 20 drawing of the California Super Lotto. The next jackpot will be at least $31 million.

DIVAS ON A DIME: Secret tips for hiding vegetables from picky eaters

Even the most enthusiastic vegetable lovers can have a hard time getting that five a day. But when you have kids who act like you’re trying to poison them with peas, it’s even harder. That said, I’m not above suggesting you sneak veggies into your children’s food. Welcome to this episode of Crouching Mother, Hidden Veggies.