76°F
weather icon Clear

Nevada hearing on Hof’s license revocations postponed

The hearing before U.S. District Court Judge Richard Boulware on Nevada businessman and political candidate Dennis Hof’s most recent lawsuit against Nye County took place Aug. 22 but the ultimate decision has been postponed.

Judge Boulware encouraged the delay in order to allow Nye County to gather additional evidence to bolster its defense against Hof’s allegations of First and 14th Amendment rights violations because as the record stood that morning, he was of a mind to order the county to reopen Hof’s businesses and restore his licenses to him. The hearing is now set for Monday, Aug. 27 at the Lloyd D. George U.S. Courthouse, 333 Las Vegas Blvd. South, Las Vegas.

Overview

At the heart of the lawsuit is the county’s decision not to renew Hof’s brothel and liquor licenses and the subsequent closure of Hof’s Love Ranch South brothel and Crystal Watering Hole. Named in the lawsuit are Nye County, the Nye County Liquor and Licensing Board and commissioners Dan Schinhofen and Butch Borasky in their professional and personal capacities.

Hof’s legal representation, Randazza Legal Group, submitted a 99-page motion for a temporary restraining order outlining myriad allegations, claiming a lack of due process on the part of the county, improper recusal procedure, retaliation and more.

Additionally, just prior to the initial hearing that took place August 22, Randazza Legal Group submitted a “deposition of person most knowledgeable” recorded with Callie Stark, an Administrative Tech II for the Nye County Sheriff’s Office.

The deposition detailed an interview between Stark and Hof’s legal team, as well as the county’s POOL/PACT legal representative, Rebecca Bruch, regarding Stark’s responsibilities in managing business license documents and related payments to the county. One reason given by the commissioners, who voted in favor of revoking Hof’s licenses, was an apparently late-filed renewal slip and late payment for his brothel license.

In the extensive deposition document, Stark is recorded as stating that the renewal slip that the county stated must be submitted by a certain deadline was considered by the sheriff’s office to be “irrelevant.” Stark further stated that the regular practice had not been to track precisely when license payments were received by the county and that the date by which they were submitted was not recorded.

Due to the fact that the deposition was filed so shortly before Wednesday’s hearing, judge Boulware asked the county whether they had anything to add in relation to the subject. Bruch explained that the county had nothing to dispute in the deposition but she would like the chance to provide additional information as well as call witnesses, such as Nye County Commissioner and liquor and licensing board chairwoman Lorinda Wichman.

Identified issues in county defense

Boulware offered to reschedule the hearing to allow Bruch and the county to review the document and add to its defense. Before doing so, however, Boulware took time to expound on a few “issues” he had found in the record of submissions in the case.

Boulware stated that the county had spent very little time addressing Hof’s claims of First Amendment violations, stressing that it was his, Boulware’s, duty to decide whether the county’s actions were in fact retaliatory. Hof’s allegation of selective enforcement of county code was another accusation Boulware said he felt the county might want to provide some sort of defense of.

“I wanted to give you the opportunity to rebut and let you know the potential issues I see,” Boulware told Bruch. He went further to note that based on the information in the record at that moment, there was a “significant possibility” that he would order the licenses be reinstated and the businesses reopened at the continued hearing. The decision hinges upon the evidence presented by the county at the August 27 hearing, Boulware stated.

As for Bruch’s witnesses, Boulware cautioned her from focusing on a line of questioning that would delineate the thoughts and reasoning of the commissioners who voted in favor of pulling Hof’s licenses, as he believed that was reflected in the minutes of that meeting and part of the record already. Rather, testimony geared toward disputing the allegations of retaliatory behavior, lack of due process and selective enforcement, which was largely missing, would be more to the point, he advised.

Before the hearing adjourned for the morning, Mark Randazza of Randazza Legal Group said he did not wish to provide any additional evidence at the rescheduled hearing but that he may wish to question commissioner Schinhofen at that time. Boulware remarked that as a defendant in a federal lawsuit, he felt it would be prudent for Schinhofen to be there.

The hearing is set for 9:30 a.m. on Aug. 27.

Contact reporter Robin Hebrock at rhebrock@pvtimes.com

THE LATEST
Plan for medical waste treatment plant draws public outcry

A proposal by MediWaste Disposal LLC to bring a medical waste treatment facility to the valley has touched off a wave of public unrest, with a crowd of Pahrump residents flocking to the latest Nye County Commission meeting to express their displeasure.

3 motorcyclists killed in US 95 crash near Goldfield

Three motorcyclists who died in a crash along US 95 about 2 miles south of Goldfield last week have been identified as Benny Hall, 52, of Tonopah; Jeffery Hicks, 72, of Goldfield; and Frank Winkler, 54, of Linton, Ind.

How Pahrump is remembering its heroes this Memorial Day weekend

Though it has become widely known as the unofficial kickoff of summer, two local veterans’ organizations are helping ensure the real meaning of Memorial Day is not lost among the fun of pool parties and cookouts.

Groundbreaking set for new Tonopah elementary school

A ground-breaking ceremony is set for the construction of the new $25 million Tonopah Elementary School beginning at 10 a.m. on Wednesday, May 29

Nye schools seek retirees to fill some critical vacancies

Even as school officials announced the retirement of more than a dozen teachers and other personnel on Monday night, they hope some veteran workers and retirees will consider returning to fill essential roles in the district.

GALLERY: Pinkbox Pahrump grand opening

When asked why Pahrump, owner of Pinkbox Stephen Siegel responds with, “why not?”

Fire destroys property, vehicles on Our Road

No injuries were reported after fire consumed two structures and vehicles on Sunday, May 19, just after 12:30 p.m.

RENDERING: Rhyolite Ridge gains formal county support

The Bureau of Land Management published its draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the Rhyolite Ridge Lithium-Boron project in April, triggering another crucial step forward for the planned mining operation – the public comment period. The deadline to submit is June 3.