65°F
weather icon Overcast

Nevada’s Adam Laxalt joins fight over contested water order for Pahrump

Updated March 8, 2018 - 11:34 am

In the latest action surrounding Nevada State Engineer Order #1293, Nevada Attorney General Adam Laxalt has joined the fight on the side of the state engineer’s office. Laxalt is representing the engineer’s office in the lawsuit filed by Pahrump Fair Water LLC, a group of local citizens seeking to put a stop to the order.

On Feb. 28, Laxalt filed opposition to the association’s motion for stay and Pahrump Fair Water’s reaction was rife with frustration. In a letter sent out via email, the association blasted Laxalt’s filing, accusing the attorney general of attempting to muzzle those protesting against the order.

Nevada State Engineer Jason King issued Order #1293 in December 2017 at the direct request of the Nye County Water District Governing Board, sparking immediate disquiet in the Pahrump community.

Order #1293 created restrictions on the drilling of new domestic wells in the Pahrump Valley, requiring any new domestic well to have two acre-feet of water rights relinquished prior to being drilled.

While some valley lots already have water rights associated with them, many do not, leaving those property owners without any option but to purchase costly water rights in order to develop their land.

The arguments

Pahrump Fair Water LLC has alleged that this action will cause damage to those property owners as well as to the business owners and real estate agents involved in the association and the overall economic well-being of the county and town as a whole. Laxalt, on the other hand, asserted that Pahrump Fair Water LLC has no legal standing to request a stay.

“It is factually impossible for petitioner to be irreparably harmed if a stay of Order #1293 is not issued as it does not own any land or otherwise have an interest that is affected by the order,” Laxalt’s opposition filing stated. “Petitioner does not have any legal interest in the basin.”

The argument of legal standing revolves around a technicality, with Laxalt noting that as a limited liability company that did not exist until after Order #1293 was issued, Pahrump Fair Water LLC is not affected by the order. The filing read, “…a limited liability company is an entity distinct from its managers and members.”

Laxalt’s opposition contains various other arguments as well, including his belief that a stay of Order #1293 would harm the public. In addition to declarations regarding potential negative impacts to water supply, Laxalt predicted a rash of drilling if a stay were granted.

“If a stay is issued but the state engineer succeeds on merit … any well drilled between issuance of the stay and a final determination in this action will result in an avoidable injury to those persons who may rely on the stay,” Laxalt stated. “If Order #1293 is upheld, then each of those wells would be required to be plugged …”

Fierce reaction

Following Laxalt’s filing, Pahrump Fair Water distributed its email criticizing the action.

“Not only is Attorney General Laxalt aggressively defending the state engineer’s unwillingness to hear the concerns of Pahrump citizens before he issued the order, he is now also seeking to silence those same citizens …” the release said. “The motion filed … characterizes the concerns expressed by the citizens as ‘impertinent,’ ‘immaterial’ and ‘irrelevant’ despite the fact that they directly relate to the issues raised in the appeal.”

Pahrump Fair Water Managing Member and Pahrump real estate agent Norma Jean Opatik was quoted as stating, “This is truly incredible … Attorney General Laxalt, one of our elected representatives who is supposed to defend our constitutional right to be heard, is suggesting that we are being ‘impertinent’ for daring to exercise our right to challenge the state engineer.”

A request for comment from Laxalt’s office was made but a response has not yet been received.

The Office of the Attorney General is required by law to represent the Nevada State Engineer’s Office in litigation, as dictated by Nevada Revised Statute 228.110(1)(a). Nevada Revised Statute 533.450 section 11 also states that the state engineer shall request the Attorney General to appear in any litigation that the engineer believes may adversely affect the right of the public in water.

The case has been filed with the Fifth Judicial District Court Department 2 under case number CV 38972.

Contact reporter Robin Hebrock at rhebrock@pvtimes.com. On Twitter: @pvtimes

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
THE LATEST
Local Salvation Army hit by thieves

As Pahrump’s Salvation Army prepares to serve families in need during the holiday season, approximately $500 worth of new toys set aside for its annual Angel Tree program were recently stolen, along with Christmas decorations and items being stored for the Kiwanis Club and Pahrump’s Sleep In Heavenly Peace organization.

Pahrump community comes together for Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving is a time for appreciation and for hundreds of Pahrump area residents and visitors, there was plenty to be grateful for this year at the Pahrump Holiday Task Force’s annual Community Thanksgiving Dinner.

Pahrump Valley Academy virtual town hall set for Saturday

Throughout much of 2019 and into 2020, a group of local residents hoping to add a new educational option to the valley worked diligently toward establishing Pahrump Valley Academy, which would have been the valley’s very first public charter school, only to have the proposal nixed in early 2020.

Rotary Club encouraging students to read

The Pahrump Rotary Club has performed countless community service projects since its inception in 1987.

Bowling for Our Wounded Warriors – Fundraiser set for Dec. 5

Donning a U.S. armed forces uniform is something that comes with great risk and the men and women who step up to take on the challenge of protecting America through military service often come home with injuries, both the visible and the invisible kind.

Man calls 911 while speaking to deputies, report says

Nye County Sheriff’s Office deputies arrested a man who allegedly called 911 for a complaint about loud music at a residence along South Chippewa Street last week but ended up getting arrested himself.

Development of Pahrump’s Kellogg Park tracking right along

Development of Pahrump’s newest park, Kellogg Park on the southern end of the valley, continues to move along steadily, with a variety of milestones reached in recent months and officials with the town of Pahrump and Nye County now setting their sights on the next steps of the development process.

PLAC to decide on Rough Hat recommendations; meeting Nov. 30 in Pahrump

Throughout its many years, the Pahrump Public Lands Advisory Committee hasn’t seen a whole lot of community involvement, with the group historically hosting its monthly meetings amid almost empty audiences.

Together With Veterans hosting SWOT assessment meeting in Pahrump

The men and women who have served in the United States military have given of themselves, made sacrifices on a daily basis and put the safety of others before themselves in order to protect America but when service comes to an end and they return to civilian life, the transition can be jarring.

Beatty Advisory Board deals with trails, racing, blue light

There will be no informal election to choose appointees to the Beatty Town Advisory Board. Randy Reed and Erika Gerling, whose terms expire at the end of the year, were the only people to submit letters of interest, so the Board voted, at their Nov. 22 meeting, to forward their names to the Board of County Commissioners for reappointment.