weather icon Mostly Cloudy

Roundup and relocation of wild horses not working

I think I’ve finally found something cattle ranchers and horse huggers agree on: The Bureau of Land Management is doing it wrong.

It doesn’t take a degree in rocket science to recognize the challenge the BLM has managing the West’s wild horse herds, most of which roam in Nevada. But a lack of a scientific approach is precisely one of the BLM’s deficiencies, an independent study of the complex environmental and political issue by the National Academy of Sciences has found.

The U.S. government, with the BLM riding herd, has relocated more than 100,000 horses in the past decade in an attempt to protect habitat, control overpopulation and appease ranchers and wild horse advocates.

Not surprisingly, the animals left behind keep making more horses. Although it’s tempting to wonder aloud whether the government understands how this is happening, the more important point is that it’s obvious even to the untrained observer the current system of roundup and relocation isn’t working.

Unless, of course, the goal is BLM job security.

Despite some critical findings, the BLM put a happy face on the report critics have called scathing.

The bureau’s Principal Deputy Director Neil Kornze enthused, “We commend the National Academy of Sciences for their diligent work on this complex issue. The BLM looks forward to reviewing the report in detail and building on the report’s findings and recommendations to meet the formidable challenges facing the agency in managing wild horses and burros. Our agency is committed to protecting and managing these iconic animals for current and future generations.

“The BLM shares the committee’s view that although no quick or easy fixes exist to this pressing issue, investments in science-based management approaches, exploring additional opportunities for population control, and increased transparency could lead to a more cost-effective program that manages wild horses and burros with greater public confidence.”

A BLM spokesman told a Southern Nevada radio station, “We’re please to have the results. … There are no quick or easy fixes to the various management issues. We look forward to looking at implementing everything that makes sense.”

But “implementing everything that makes sense” to a government agency might not “make sense” to the various and vocal groups whose opinions on wild horses range from issuing the animals contraception to using them for dog food.

In addition to calling for greater transparency, the NAS observed: “Evidence suggests that horse populations are growing by 15 to 20 percent each year, a level that is unsustainable for maintaining healthy horse populations as well as healthy ecosystems. However, promising fertility-control methods are available to help limit this population growth. In addition, science-based methods exist for improving population estimates and predicting the effects of management practices in order to maintain genetically diverse, healthy populations, and estimating the productivity of rangelands.” (The 461-page NAS report is available online at dels.nas.edu.)

Not exactly an endorsement of business-as-usual at the BLM Ranch.

Those who favor the status quo might have cringed at recent headlines vilifying the BLM, but they also know that even the most scathing indictments from the most credible academies fade quickly in the media and are far more likely to gather dust on a shelf than generate action in the halls of Congress.

Will this time be different?

Like many Nevadans, I appreciate our state’s identity as a place wild horses still run and are protected. But at some point someone in authority is going to have to step up and admit the roundups haven’t worked.

My proposal is simpler and probably proves why no one at the NAS has asked me to join their group.

I say keep the waterholes open and let nature take care of the rest.

It’s unscientific. But it makes more sense than asking a federal bureaucracy to play reluctant cowboy.

Nevada native John L. Smith also writes a daily column for the Las Vegas Review-Journal. Contact him at 702 383-0295 or atjsmith@reviewjournal.com.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
Nevada police agencies to receive grant monies

At least $1.4 million in a Community Policing Development (CPD) program will make its way to Nevada to help support law enforcement officers.

VICTOR JOECKS: How Joe Biden stole Christmas

Christmas classics would be a lot different if they had been written during President Joe Biden’s administration.

Motorcycle crash prompts Mercy Air response

A structure fire on the 4400 block of East Paiute Boulevard prompted the response of Pahrump Valley Fire and Rescue Services crews.

Mizpah rates high in list of haunted stops

Under an agreement between conservationists and a federal agency, a finding must be issued by the end of the month.

Sisolak prepares for ‘heated year’ ahead of 2022 election

Gov. Steve Sisolak, in an interview at the governor’s mansion in Carson City, said he prays daily for guidance in handling the COVID pandemic.

Beatty VFW Memory Garden Dedicated

The Beatty VFW Memory Garden is now open and was dedicated Oct. 9 during the VFW post’s Fall Festival, which featured food, art and craft booths, and a silent auction.

Airport signs to soon show ‘Harry Reid’ as new name

Work could commence soon on updating signage at McCarran International Airport to reflect the name change to Harry Reid International Airport.

Ground turkey products recalled

Butterball, LLC, a Mount Olive, N.C. establishment, is recalling approximately 14,107 pounds of ground turkey products that may be contaminated with extraneous materials, specifically blue plastic, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS).

Nevada Highway Patrol receives $100k public safety grant

By putting in additional efforts to combat drunk and distracted drivers along Silver State roadways, the Nevada Department of Public Safety, Highway Patrol Division has received a grant in the amount of $100,000 from the Nevada Department of Public Safety, Office of Traffic Safety for targeted DUI enforcement campaigns during the coming year.