weather icon Clear

STEVE SEBELIUS: Don’t let our political fights end in a constitutional convention

Democrats have had a lot to worry about in 2020.

The fourth year of a Donald Trump administration. A lawsuit that could end up repealing the signature achievement of the last Democratic president, the Affordable Care Act. A third Trump appointment to the U.S. Supreme Court.

But 2020 has never disappointed in one respect: its ability to show that things could always get worse. How about the idea of a constitutional convention that red states might use to enact permanent conservative reforms?

That’s what concerns former Democratic Wisconsin U.S. Sen. Russ Feingold, who spoke to a virtual audience at the William S. Boyd School of Law last week. Feingold says he thinks enough states might be ready to call a convention “in the not-to-distant future.”

If they do, it will be a first.

The Constitution has been amended 18 times since it was ratified in 1787, first with the 10-item Bill of Rights and then 17 more times, but always as a result of congressional action. Under Article 5, however, two-thirds of the states (34) can also call for a convention to propose amendments.

And if they did, Feingold said, there are no rules: The convention could decide what amendments to propose and how they may be considered and approved. (The only rule in Article 5 preserves the Great Compromise, stipulating that no state can be deprived of its two U.S. senators without that state’s consent.)

That means everything is on the table: a balanced budget amendment, term limits for members of Congress or the Supreme Court, a ban on abortion or gay rights or flag burning, even repealing the direct election of senators. Congress could not intervene, nor could the president. The only check on the process is the requirement that the legislatures of three-fourths of the states (38) adopt the proposed amendments.

For Democrats, it could be a nightmare.

It means that even if former Vice President Joe Biden is elected in November, and even if Democrats retain the majority in the House and even if they retake the Senate, and even if they pass legislation to expand the number of justices on the Supreme Court and even if they pass legislation to expand voting rights, abortion rights or repeal unpopular court rulings such as Citizens United, a constitutional convention could undo all of those actions.

“I think there may be an attempt to seriously gut the Constitution,” Feingold told the Boyd audience. “Constitutional amendments are brought up when you can’t get things done through the normal route.”

And we all know how well the normal route has worked in the past 20 years or so.

Feingold noted most of the amendments (with the exception of Prohibition) have tended to be progressive reforms, but the weight of history has no more control of a constitutional convention than anything else. “Article 5, which some people consider the mega-provision of the Constitution” because of its ability to change fundamental rules and rights, Feingold said.

The truth is, contrary to popular belief, our rights don’t come from God; they come because Americans collectively said it was so and wrote it down in a pact that we’ve all agreed to follow. But that pact can be changed, and Article 5 is how.

Certainly, there are plenty of amendments Democrats would like to see added, such as campaign finance rules, or restrictions on gun rights, or enshrining abortion rights, equal rights for women or even a fundamental right to vote in the Constitution. They’d probably like to install policies to fight climate change, or clarify that the free exercise of religion doesn’t exempt anyone from the obligation to follow nondiscriminatory, generally applicable laws.

It’s this kind of open-ended, no-holds-barred power that prompted the late Justice Antonin Scalia to exclaim, “I certainly would not want a constitutional convention. Whoa! Who knows what would come out of it?”

The convention option has gained currency as the legislative branch has become more partisan, less willing to work across party lines and compromise on issues of controversy. As a result, more and more issues are resolved by the judicial branch.

Perhaps if more people of both parties could agree to work under the Constitution we have, to put aside political concerns once the election was over, and to compromise in an attempt to solve the real problems faced by real people, there’d be less consideration of nuclear options.

Hasn’t 2020 done enough already?

Contact Steve Sebelius at SSebelius@reviewjournal.com or 702-383-0253.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
Chamber to host two candidate nights

The Pahrump Valley Chamber of Commerce is hosting multiple sessions of its Zoom Candidates Forum, in what the chamber is calling a “nonpartisan, unbiased and impartial event.”

Commissioner-elect Richard “Dick” Gardner dies

On Monday, Oct. 26 Nye County Commissioner-elect Richard “Dick” Gardner died, leaving not just a vacant seat for the board come 2021, but a community mourning the loss of one of its own as well.

Former Health and Human Services secretary speaks about rural health care

Kathleen Sebelius, former secretary of Health and Human Services and Kansas Governor, speaks with the Pahrump Valley Times. Sebelius touched on rural health care, the Affordable Care Act and the impending vote on Amy Coney Barrett, President Donald Trump’s Supreme Court nominee.

Multiple schools in Pahrump affected by COVID-19

Multiple schools have had staff members test positive for COVID-19 in recent weeks. Pahrump Valley High School also announced that someone at the school has tested positive in a letter to families on its website.

State reports 1,146 new COVID-19 cases, 5 deaths

For the first time since Aug. 14, more than 1,000 new cases were reported in Nevada on Saturday, according to the Department of Health and Human Services.

USDA works to expand rural broadband

The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) is now accepting applications for funding to provide broadband service in undeserved rural areas. Broadband service is the speed of your internet. This new grant will be available in the year 2021 under the Community Connect Grant program.

Tuatara comes to the finish line on highway 160

The motor of the now record-breaking SSC Tuatara wound down to its final stop along Highway 160, near Tecopa Road, on Oct. 10.

Helicopter crashes into Lake Spring Mountain

No serious injuries were reported following the crash of a helicopter in a lake at the Spring Mountain Motor Resort and Country Club just after 10 a.m., on Friday morning, Oct. 16.

Nye County waives brothel licensing fees, rejects same request for pot industry

In the face of COVID-19, many businesses in Nye County have seen negative impacts and have been struggling to keep afloat as the pandemic continues to hold sway over government mandated restriction. In a lot of cases, those businesses have been able to turn to federal, state and local programs for assistance but not so for the brothel and marijuana industries, which are barred from utilizing a majority, if not all, of the available programs.

Impact statement for Lee Canyon plans now available

The Humboldt-Toiyabe National Forest on Oct. 9 published the Notice of Availability of the final Lee Canyon Master Development Plan Phase I Environmental Impact Statement for a 30-day review period.