weather icon Partly Cloudy

Twitter pics prompt notice of violation in Hof lawsuit

Updated September 13, 2018 - 3:58 pm

In a continuation of the most recent lawsuit from brothel owner and Nevada Assembly District 36 candidate Dennis Hof, Nye County has filed a notice of violation in the case, citing allegedly illegally captured photographs taken by Hof.

On Monday, Aug. 27, U.S. District Judge Richard Boulware presided over a hearing in case 2:18-cv-01492-RFB-GWF. The hearing was regarding a lawsuit filed by Hof following the county’s decision to revoke his brothel and liquor licenses.

The judge ruled in favor of a temporary injunction to allow Hof to reopen his businesses. At the same hearing, Hof also snapped some images inside the courtroom, which is expressly prohibited, with signs notifying all entering the courtroom of the restriction. This became public knowledge when Hof decided to post the photos to Twitter following the hearing, prompting the county’s notice of violation.

According to United States District Court District of Nevada’s Local Rules of Practice LR IA 2-1 (b), “All wireless communication devices must be turned off while in any United States courtroom or hearing room in this district, unless the presiding judge authorizes otherwise. Wireless communication devices are electronic devices that are capable of either sending or receiving data such as sounds, text messages or images, including but not limited to mobile phones, laptop computers and tablets.”

This is the rule that the county’s notice of violation honed in on. “The Twitter posts contained two pictures… One was of a bench and the back of plaintiff’s counsel’s heads; the other picture was of commissioner Schinhofen and former planning director Darrell Lacy, who were in attendance. The Twitter posts contained language which plaintiff has an absolute First Amendment right to post to the entire world. Plaintiff does not have a right under LR IA 2-1 to take pictures inside the courtroom without permission of the court,” the notice detailed.

The county requested that the court, “…admonish plaintiff that he is not permitted to take pictures in the courthouse for any purpose absent permission…”

In the response filed by Hof’s legal team, his attorneys described the notice of violation an “unnecessary addition to the docket” but declined to speculate on why the county might have filed it.

Rather, the document claimed that Hof was not the only person in the room who was using a camera at the time and regardless, once the audience had been told they were not allowed to record anything inside the room, Hof ceased to do so.

“Mr. Hof, like other spectators in the courtroom, including at least one journalist, was using his camera prior to the hearing. Counsel was unaware of this… At some point the judge entered the room, the bailiff instructed all spectators that no photography was allowed in the building. At that point, it appears to have ended,” Hof’s response contended. “The two photographs are clearly from this time before the hearing and before the bailiff’s instruction. Nevertheless, counsel is completely capable of informing their clients of the fact that federal courts do not allow cameras…”

The lawsuit is still pending a final decision.

Contact reporter Robin Hebrock at rhebrock@pvtimes.com

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
Nellis airman killed in US 95 rollover crash near Nye County

Four Nellis Air Force airmen were seriously injured and one died after a rollover crash early Wednesday on U.S. Highway 95 near Lee Canyon Road.

10 firearms stolen from Pahrump home

The Nye County Sheriff’s Office is seeking information on the theft of multiple firearms from a local home.

Pahrump’s Mountain Falls gets thumbs up for 52 more homes

After delaying a request for approval for a tentative subdivision map for Mountain Falls, the Nye County Commission readdressed the item at its July 16 meeting, eventually giving the tentative map the green light with a 4-1 vote.

Helping hands turn Pahrump house into home

The Pahrump Valley Rotary Club is an organization dedicated to community service, touting the slogan, “service above self” and it is always actively seeking ways to help the community it calls home.

Pahrump nonprofit enhancing its space through grant

A Pahrump nonprofit that focuses on addiction rehabilitation services has gotten a boost from the Home Depot Foundation.

Nye County District Attorney’s Report

Editor’s note: The Nye County District Attorney’s Report is provided by the office of DA Chris Arabia. Plans call for it to be provided on a monthly basis as the information becomes available. Duplicate names represent separate cases. See pvtimes.com for a look at recent DA reports.

Celebration set for brownfields project in Nye County

The community is invited to attend a celebration marking the first successful brownfield cleanup completed by the Nevada Rural Brownfields Partnership utilizing the revolving loan fund, the Rural Desert Southwest Brownfields Coalition announced.